WordPress Multisite: When It Makes Sense (And When to Avoid It)

WordPress Multisite lets you run multiple sites from a single WordPress installation. It sounds efficient, but comes with significant trade-offs.

This guide helps you decide if Multisite is right for you—and what alternatives exist.

---

What Is WordPress Multisite?

Multisite (formerly MU - Multi-User) is a WordPress feature that creates a network of sites sharing:

• One WordPress installation

• One database

• One set of plugins

• One set of themes

Each site in the network can have:

• Different content

• Different subdomain or subdirectory

• Different active theme (from shared pool)

• Different users

---

How Multisite Works

Network Structure

WordPress Installation
├── Network Admin
│   ├── All Sites
│   ├── All Users
│   ├── All Themes
│   └── All Plugins
│
├── Site 1 (main.example.com)
│   └── Site Admin
│
├── Site 2 (blog.example.com)
│   └── Site Admin
│
└── Site 3 (store.example.com)
    └── Site Admin

URL Structures

Subdirectory:

example.com/site1
example.com/site2
example.com/site3

Subdomain:

site1.example.com
site2.example.com
site3.example.com

Custom domains:

site1.com
site2.com
site3.com

(Requires domain mapping plugin or configuration)

---

When Multisite Makes Sense

✅ Good Use Cases

1. University/School Networks

• Many departments, one platform

• Centralized management

• Shared resources

2. Franchise Networks

• Same branding, localized content

• Controlled theme/plugin options

• Central updates

3. Multiple City/Location Sites

• example.com/new-york

• example.com/los-angeles

• Shared base, localized content

4. Development Agencies

• Host client sites on shared infrastructure

• Centralized maintenance

• Bulk updates

5. Multilingual Sites

• One network, multiple languages

• Shared media library possible

• Centralized management

---

When Multisite Is Wrong

❌ Bad Use Cases

1. Unrelated Sites

• Different owners

• Different purposes

• Different hosting needs

2. Sites with Different Scale

• One site gets 90% of traffic

• Others affected by its load

3. Sites Needing Different Plugins

• One site needs WooCommerce

• Another needs completely different stack

4. Sites with Different Security Needs

• One handles payments

• One is a simple blog

5. Sites That Might Be Sold/Transferred

• Extracting a Multisite site is painful

---

The Problems with Multisite

Problem 1: Plugin Conflicts

Plugins activate network-wide or per-site, but:

• Some plugins don't support Multisite

• Plugin conflicts affect all sites

• A bad plugin takes down the network

Problem 2: Performance Issues

All sites share resources:

• High traffic on one site affects others

• Database queries get complex

• Caching becomes complicated

-- Multisite creates tables per site
wp_2_posts
wp_2_postmeta
wp_3_posts
wp_3_postmeta
-- ... and so on

Problem 3: Complexity

• Super Admin vs Site Admin confusion

• Plugin/theme activation complexity

• Backup/restore is all-or-nothing

• Migration is extremely difficult

Problem 4: Single Point of Failure

One hack = all sites compromised

If the WordPress core or a network plugin is exploited, every site in the network is at risk.

Problem 5: Hosting Limitations

Many hosts don't support Multisite or charge extra:

• Shared hosting: Often no Multisite

• Managed WordPress: Multisite may cost more

• Special configuration needed

---

Multisite Setup Basics

If you decide to proceed:

Enable Multisite

Add to wp-config.php:

define('WP_ALLOW_MULTISITE', true);

Configure Network

After enabling, go to Tools → Network Setup and follow prompts.

Add the generated code to wp-config.php:

define('MULTISITE', true);
define('SUBDOMAIN_INSTALL', false);
define('DOMAIN_CURRENT_SITE', 'example.com');
define('PATH_CURRENT_SITE', '/');
define('SITE_ID_CURRENT_SITE', 1);
define('BLOG_ID_CURRENT_SITE', 1);

Add to .htaccess the rules WordPress provides.

Managing the Network

• Network Admin → Manage all sites, users, themes, plugins

• Site Admin → Manage individual site content

---

Alternatives to Multisite

Alternative 1: MainWP

Manage multiple separate WordPress sites from one dashboard.

Feature

MainWP

Bulk updates

✅

Backup management

✅

Security scanning

✅

Site cloning

✅

Separate installations

✅

Best for: Agencies managing client sites

Alternative 2: ManageWP

Cloud-based management of multiple WordPress sites.

Similar to MainWP but SaaS-based. No self-hosting the dashboard.

Alternative 3: InfiniteWP

Self-hosted multi-site management.

Like MainWP, you install a controller that manages satellite sites.

Alternative 4: Separate Installations

Sometimes the simplest solution:

• Each site is independent

• No shared vulnerabilities

• Easy to migrate/sell individual sites

• Use management tool for bulk operations

---

Modern Architecture Alternatives

Headless CMS + Static Sites

For organizations with many sites:

Sanity (CMS)
├── Site 1 data
├── Site 2 data
└── Site 3 data

Each site:
├── Pulls from Sanity
├── Builds independently
└── Deploys to CDN

Benefits:

• True independence

• No shared vulnerabilities

• Scale infinitely

• Real isolation

Monorepo Approach

/monorepo
├── /packages
│   ├── /shared-components
│   └── /shared-styles
├── /sites
│   ├── /site-1
│   ├── /site-2
│   └── /site-3
└── package.json (workspaces)

Benefits:

• Share code, not infrastructure

• Deploy independently

• Version control everything

• No database complexity

Multi-Tenant SaaS

Build once, serve many:

// Tenant-based routing
export async function middleware(request) {
  const hostname = request.headers.get('host');
  const tenant = getTenantFromHostname(hostname);
  
  // Rewrite to tenant-specific content
  return NextResponse.rewrite(
    new URL(/${tenant}${request.nextUrl.pathname}, request.url)
  );
}

Benefits:

• One codebase

• One deployment

• But proper isolation

• True multi-tenancy

---

Migration from Multisite

Extracting a site from Multisite is painful but possible:

Manual Process

1. Export content via WordPress export

2. Create new single-site WordPress

3. Import content

4. Migrate theme and customizations

5. Migrate plugin settings

6. Update URLs throughout

7. Set up redirects

Using Plugins

• NS Cloner - Clone Multisite to single site

• WP Migrate DB Pro - Database migration tools

• All-in-One WP Migration - May work with tweaks

Time Estimate

Simple site: 2-4 hours

Complex site: 1-2 days

E-commerce: Multiple days

---

Decision Framework

Ask these questions:

1. Do sites share theme/plugins?

Yes → Multisite possible

No → Separate installations

2. Will sites grow at different rates?

Yes → Separate installations

No → Multisite possible

3. Might a site be sold/transferred?

Yes → Separate installations

No → Multisite possible

4. Different security requirements?

Yes → Separate installations

No → Multisite possible

5. Do you have resources to manage complexity?

Yes → Consider Multisite

No → Separate with management tool

---

FAQ

Q: Can I convert an existing site to Multisite?

Yes, but it's complex. Better to start fresh and migrate content.

Q: Can different sites have different plugins?

Yes, plugins can be activated per-site. But all sites share the plugin files.

Q: What about security updates?

One update applies to all sites—efficient but risky if update causes issues. See WordPress security guide →

Q: How do I backup individual sites?

Difficult. Most backup solutions backup the entire network. Extracting one site requires export/import. Learn about WordPress exports →

---

Conclusion

Use Multisite When:

• Sites genuinely share infrastructure needs

• You have technical resources for management

• Sites won't need to be separated

• Security requirements are uniform

Avoid Multisite When:

• Sites are fundamentally different

• You might sell/transfer sites

• Resources are limited for complexity

• Sites have different scaling needs

Consider Alternatives:

• MainWP/ManageWP for managing separate sites

• Headless CMS for modern multi-site architecture

• Monorepo for code sharing without infrastructure sharing

The trend is moving away from Multisite toward more isolated, manageable architectures.

Related guides:

• Headless CMS vs Traditional CMS

• Choose a Headless CMS Guide

• JAMstack Explained

Explore modern multi-site alternatives →